To Joey & Brooke, I’ve written a lot of words on this site, but none …
After a lifespan that has begun to rival even that of his two best-known outlets, it’s worth asking what might be considered a tough question: Would anyone give Puscifer the time of day if Maynard James Keenan wasn’t involved?
MORE: GREG PUCIATO: Fear Is The Mind-Killer // iDKHOW: Retro Music For The Modern Era REVIEWS: MR BUNGLE: The Raging Wrath of the Easter Bunny Demo // BRING ME THE HORIZON: POST HUMAN:SURVIVAL HORROR // ALPHA WOLF: a quiet place to die // MARILYN MANSON: We Are Chaos // iDKHOW: RAZZMATAZZ // PALLBEARER: Forgotten Days // LIKE MOTHS TO FLAMES: No Eternity In Gold
Consider an alternate timeline in which the project wasn’t helmed by an alt-metal giant of the 90s and 2000s, and that someone with no backstory to their name otherwise was putting out this scattershot, quasi-industrial artsy-fartsy. Would it fill theatres, chart in the top 40 and have as many eyes (first, second and third) on it as it does now? The answer, admittedly, is a little complicated. Yes, the project literally would not exist without Keenan–forged in the midst of Tool‘s run in the mid-90s as a darkly-humourous creative outlet–but as the years have gone on, it’s largely turned into more of a collective effort. Musicians such as vocalist/multi-instrumentalist Carina Round and guitarist/producer Mat Mitchell have increased their presence within the Puscifer project in more recent years–so much so, they even feature alongside Keenan himself in the official Puscifer press shots for 2020.
Wading through the hour-long Existential Reckoning–the project’s fourth official studio album–one finds a lot of the same issues arising that plagued both A Perfect Circle‘s Eat the Elephant in 2018 and Tool‘s Fear Inoculum in 2019. Chief among them is that Keenan himself has become among the least interesting things about the music. This, to be fair, is not as noticeable when it’s within the dynamic of a band–especially ones home to such talented musicians as Billy Howerdel and Danny Carey. When it’s within the confines of the music considered synonymous with being your side project, however, the creative wear-and-tear really begins to show.
Existential Reckoning, by means of contrast, is a sepia dirge. It’s an unremarkable effort from someone who has created extraordinary works in the past–and not even the talents of his cohorts can lift him from resting on his laurels.
The album is born under a bad sign from the opening moments of Bread and Circus, which is home to some of the shrillest, nastiest synthesizer tone you’re likely to hear in 2020. It may be ugly by design, but it stretches the friendship to the point of it being nigh-on unlistenable. It’s salvaged somewhat in its back half by Round complementing Keenan’s vocal singing in … well, round. It’s not quite enough to save the whole song, however, and not much can save its atonal follow-up Apocalyptical. Keenan’s vocals here are truly nails on a chalkboard, reliant on a breathy whine that does not serve the song at all.
Fake Affront offers some respite, its bustling post-punk beat and Peter Hook-inspired bass adding some liveliness to the record. Bonus points for Round’s cheerful call-and-response of “Shut the fuck up!” serving as one of the highlights of the entire record. There’s a certain kick and strut to The Underwhelming too, driving home four-on-the-floor drums and new-wave synth in what feels like a homage to one of Keenan’s personal favourite bands Depeche Mode. Moments such as these, however, are ultimately too few and far between to substantiate coming back to Existential Reckoning.
For someone who’d always been lauded for having such lofty ambitions–the kind where it would take literal years for new music to surface from his projects–Keenan has rarely felt as autopilot as he has here. Even at its most crass, Puscifer’s sense of humour added a little colour to proceedings. Existential Reckoning, by means of contrast, is a sepia dirge. It’s an unremarkable effort from someone who has created extraordinary works in the past–and not even the talents of his cohorts can lift him from resting on his laurels.
STANDOUT TRACKS: Fake Affront, The Underwhelming
STICK THIS NEXT TO: Depeche Mode, Talk Talk, Tears For Fears




