To Joey & Brooke, I’ve written a lot of words on this site, but none …
There was a lot to like about the fifth album from Swedish metal innovators In Flames.
MORE: IN HEARTS WAKE: The Age Of Kaliyuga // DEFTONES: 20 Years Of White Pony // NORTHLANE: Live At The Roundhouse // IN FLAMES: A Sculpture Remade In Clay REVIEWS: BLUES PILLS: Holy Moly // NOFX/FRANK TURNER: West Coast Vs. Wessex // EMMURE: Hindsight // FANGZ: But No Thanks // IN HEARTS WAKE: Kaliyuga // SEETHER: Si Vis Pacem, Para Bellum
The second to feature the same core of members who would go on to make another four records together, the chemistry is apparent in the sonic depth across the album and the maturity of the songwriting.
Clayman is a transitional album, standing at the juncture of their death metal past and the commercial melodic sound In Flames began to pursue from this point. The signature blend of melody and menace that helped to establish the Gothenburg sound remains at the forefront, but a broader sonic palette highlights other nuances that would go on to become future hallmarks. Songs like Square Nothing and Only for the Weak point the most stridently toward the band’s future direction, injecting higher doses of electronics and sampling and Anders Fridén’s tentative steps into a cleaner, more melodic vocal style. That these are two of Clayman’s weaker tracks is evidence that In Flames were still merely dipping their toes into this kind of writing.
… the chemistry is apparent in the sonic depth across the album and the maturity of the songwriting.
Elsewhere, Pinball Map and Another Day in Quicksand are prime displays of speedy and aggressive melodic death metal In Flames style, the first one of the best songs of this era of the band and the second a showcase for their finest elements—sharp riffs, elegant solos and Fridén at his harshest. His writing partnership with Dark Tranquillity’s Niklas Sundin now over, Fridén takes his lyrics into pensive, personal directions exploring mental health and internal struggle, giving Clayman an overall darker tone than earlier albums.
Yet the catchy riffing and energetic grooves don’t make this as memorable as the three that came before it—Clayman is enjoyable enough to listen through but it’s almost forgotten as soon as it finishes. Fridén and guitarist Björn Gelotte may have subconsciously recognised this in the fairly lazy way they chose to celebrate its 20th anniversary. Gelotte’s Themes and Variations in D Minor is a nice idea as an adjunct, but the re-recorded additional tracks are unnecessary, shallow and soul-less replicas existing only to show the starkness of difference between the band then and now. Inviting the other three members who originally played on them might have made these four songs better, but instead they merely detract from Clayman’s overall quality.
STANDOUT TRACKS: Pinball Map, Another Day in Quicksand, Satellites and Astronauts
STICK THIS NEXT TO: Soilwork, Dark Tranquillity, Arch Enemy



